Prior to traveling to another library, a coworker and I were practicing RA interviews with each other. She asked me about a recent favorite book and my all-time favorite book, used NoveList to look for read-alikes, She asked a few additional questions about whether I'm comfortable with certain types of content (ie. themes of mental illness or LGBTQ relationships) then gave me three recommendations:
Author: Lee Mandelo
Published: August 16, 2022
Genre: Dark Fantasy
Author: Jennifer McMahon
Published: October 3, 2023
Genre: Horror
Author: Grady Hendrix
Published: June 14, 2022
Genre: Horror Spoof
I appreciated that my coworker took the time to explain to me the similarities between these books and the ones I had named as favorites. They all sounded like books I would enjoy. However, none of the books was available at that time. One was not in the collection (although it did get added about a week later), one was only available as an e-audiobook which I do not enjoy, and the one that was available as an e-book had a waitlist.
The next day I was attending a roundtable at a library I had never visited, and I asked a staff member there to recommend a book. She only asked, "What kind of books do you like?" and I responded, "Weird and unexpected. I enjoy a lot of Japanese authors." She asked no follow-up questions and used no resources before walking directly to a shelf and handing me:
I was fascinated that two very different approaches led to the same book. Then this staff member also walked over to the graphic novels to look for a book she remembered. She made a bit of a leap in assuming I like graphic novels since I like Japanese authors. The format is a little difficult for me to read, unless it's an e-book where I can view a single frame at a time. She wanted to recommend:
Author: Kristin Cashore; adapted by Gareth Hinds
Published: November 16, 2021
Genre: Fantasy Graphic Novel
It turns out the library did not have a print copy, but both the original book and the graphic novel adaptation were available as e-books. Although I did not learn much about questions to ask in an RA interview, I did learn how important it is that the patron leave with a book to start reading that day.




I love how you approached this assignment! Hearing how you had two different experiences was interesting. I'm always so impressed when people can think of recommendations right off the top of their head. Sometimes I feel like I forget every book I've ever read as soon as someone asks me what book I would recommend them. How did each of those recommendations fit your reading style? Were any of them books you think you would enjoy?
ReplyDeleteAllison,
DeleteI feel fortunate that I got both types of experiences. I have not read any of the recommended books yet, but The Final Girl Support Group had already been one I was interested in. I would probably read everything that was recommended, except for the graphic novel. I do read that format occasionally, but it's usually memoirs instead of fiction.
I am impressed when people can effortlessly generate recommendations, but sometimes I wonder it they are recommending books based on them liking them and not necessarily that I would like them. Did you get to read any of them yet? If you did, did you like them? I appreciate your thoughtful approach to this assignment. It was intriguing to learn about your two distinct experiences. I think it is interesting that you got the same book twice.
ReplyDeleteJackie,
DeleteMy own experience has been that I do both types of on-the-fly recommendations, depending on the situation. Sometimes it's because the patron says what they like and I know a book they would probably also like. Sometimes it's because the patron has literally no clue what they want and I go with my gut and remind them that it's free and that they don't have to finish it.
Watching that metaphorical lightbulb come on over people's heads has been a favorite part of my library experience. So many of them are afraid to check out a book because they aren't certain they'll like it, and never considered that they are reading for fun and can stop if they aren't having fun.
I haven't read any of the recommendations yet, but definitely will read The Final Girl Support Group because I was already considering it before two different people recommended it. I will probably not read Graceling, or at least not in the graphic novel format. The other two I think I would like, if I find time to get to them.
Great summary and discussion!
ReplyDelete