Skip to main content

Thriller Annotation: These Toxic Things by Rachel Howzell Hall


Title: These Toxic Things
Author: Rachel Howzell Hall
Genre: Thriller
Published: September 1, 2021
Setting: Los Angeles, CA
Time Period: Present-day
 
"Nothing worse than being by yourself when you can’t remember your life.” -- Anna (Hall, 2021)
 
Plot Summary:
 
Michaela “Mickie” Lambert is 24, lives in an apartment above her parents’ garage, and has a job compiling Memory Banks - digital scrapbooks of the memories and memorabilia provided by high-paying clients.  Mickie scans and photographs memorabilia, writes the memories into stories, and submits all this data to be turned into holograms and audio narratives which can be played on demand.
 
Mickie’s latest client, Nadia Denham, is the owner of a curiosity shop called Beautiful Things.  She wants a Memory Bank created from some of her favorite curiosities before her progressing dementia steals those memories away.  When Nadia dies under suspicious circumstances right after their first meeting, Mickie tries to complete the Memory Bank based only on the memorabilia and a few shakily written notes that Nadia left behind, a task that reveals dark secrets about Nadia’s past.

Throughout the project, Mickie also has to contend with a love triangle between herself, her coworker, and a man who may be the stalker leaving her threatening notes; rapidly-forming bonds with tenants at the strip mall housing Beautiful Things, which is destined to be demolished for new development; and the revelation of dark secrets from her own family’s past.
 
Subject Headings:
 
African American women --Fiction
California, Southern --Fiction
Holography in literature
Serial murderers --Fiction
Souvenirs (Keepsakes) --Fiction
Stalkers --Fiction
Thrillers (Fiction)
 
Thriller Appeals:
 
Pacing: “Thrillers move at a rapid pace, driven by the danger faced by the protagonist.” (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 13)
 
These Toxic Things moved quickly, with chapters just the right length to keep a reader thinking, “One more chapter,” at the end of each.  While I read most books straight through without a break, I’m usually capable of stopping.  That was not the case here.  I felt compelled to find out what was happening next.
 
Story Line: “These cinematic stories center on the plot and the action generated by the intricately involved narrative.” (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 13)
 
Intricate is a much nicer word than I was thinking.  My immediate reaction was that the plot was convoluted.  The primary storyline was easily predictable, and the final twist that is common among thrillers was more of a “Yes, and…” situation rather than a complete reversal.  The number of additional storylines was a little overwhelming, which disconnected me from the story a bit.  Nobody’s life has that many individual sources of drama.

Characterization: “Protagonists are usually strong, sympathetic characters, whether heroes or antiheroes.” (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 13)
 
While I did not dislike the protagonist, I also didn’t feel particularly sympathetic toward her.  She seemed to be a generally nice person, but I was put off by the gratuitous sex scenes in the book.  They didn’t contribute much to the progress of the plot, and I found myself angry at the protagonist for her risky choices of partners when she knew that she was being stalked and threatened.  It did not seem realistic, particularly in the face of her earlier comment of “The number of men I’ve slept with–that’s a secret, although that number is too low to be provocative” (Hall, 2021, p. 16).
 
Tone: “The tone of Thrillers is often dark, and gritty details contribute to this feel.” 
 
While a dark tone and a visually dark setting are not synonymous, they often go hand-in-hand.  I am not particularly good at visualizing what I read, which I’ve just realized is a factor in how fast I read.  Detailed descriptions of the setting and characters become irrelevant if you can’t see them in your mind.  As a fast-paced thriller, These Toxic Things was not too heavy on description, but even then my visualization is only vague shapes and colors.  This brings me to the point that I did see most of the book as dark and dreary.  The interior of the Beautiful Things shop and night-time scenes of Mickie at home took up a large portion of the plot, and the darkness made the events feel more intense and foreboding.
 
Top 3 Descriptive Terms:
 
complex, suspenseful, intriguing
 
Thriller Read-Alikes:


Title:
Before She Knew Him
Author: Peter Swanson
Published: March 5, 2019
 
Both of these thrillers tell the story of a woman meeting a new person whose mementos may be trophies of serial murder.  They are described as intricately-plotted, suspenseful, and compelling.
 

Title:
Paper Ghosts
Author: Julia Heaberlin
Published: May 15, 2018
 
Both of these thrillers feature a character with dementia who may be a serial killer.  They are described as intricately plotted and compelling.


Title:
How Can I Help You
Author: Laura Sims
Published: July 18, 2023
 
Both of these thrillers feature a woman who does creative writing based on her interactions with a serial killer.  They are described as having first-person narratives, intricately-plotted, suspenseful, and compelling.
 
Non-Fiction Recommendations:


Title:
Murderabilia: A History of Crime in 100 Objects
Author: Harold Schechter
Published: September 26, 2023
 
This non-fiction title will appeal to readers of These Toxic Things who enjoyed the insight into a serial killer’s trophies.  While the memorabilia from these
true crimes is not usually a trophy kept by the killer, the sensational crimes and the meaning imparted to objects provides a similar reading experience.


Title:
Just as Deadly: The Psychology of Female Serial Killers
Author: Marissa A. Harrison
Published: February 9, 2023
 
This non-fiction title will appeal to readers of These Toxic Things who are intrigued by female serial killers.  It includes case studies of 21 female serial killers, along with a few male serial killers used to make comparisons. 
 

Title:
You: The Story: A Writer's Guide to Craft Through Memory
Author: Ruta Sepetys
Published: May 16, 2023
 
This non-fiction title will appeal to readers of These Toxic Things who were captivated by how Mickie composed the narratives that would play when clients called up a memory from their Memory Banks.  This award-winning author of historical fiction encourages the use of personal memories to inspire and inform creative writing.
 
References
 
Hall, R.H. (2021). These toxic things. Thomas & Mercer.
 
Wyatt, N. & Saricks, J. G. (2019). The readers' advisory guide to genre fiction. ALA Editions.

Comments

  1. Wow, this plot has me intrigued and the quote you included is poignant! I especially find Mickie’s job fascinating, both in a general and personal way (my family has experience with dementia and the havoc it wreaks). I’m not familiar with the author; is this the first you have read their work?

    As for the appeals: oh my goodness, I LOVE when I find a book where I get into the “Oh, ok…just one more chapter….*5 chapters later* really, just one more…” argument with myself!! Some of my fondest memories of this is when I read the Harry Potter series as a kid, as they were being released - I was the cliché, hearing my Mom tell me I need to go to sleep for school the next day, distractedly agreeing with her and then using a flashlight under the covers to keep reading, but not keep my sister awake, too...

    For the story line, did you find that you predicted it very early on and was proven correct as you continued to read? Or as you got through the book you figured the conclusion, and that’s what took away the reveal’s impact?

    While I don’t dislike non-fiction, I usually find myself inundated by my mile-long-list of to-read fiction selections, however, your recommendation of Just As Deadly has now moved towards the top of my list! I’m a big fan of crime fiction and true crime media, and know how uncommon female serial killers are, so this book sounds fascinating.

    Thanks for such an interesting annotation and providing me with some new reads!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think I had read enough about the book prior to actually reading it that I had already figured out the main part of the plot within a couple of chapters, but there were enough side stories I was unsure about that it was still interesting.

      I had not heard of this author before. I picked one genre from each set, then used NoveList and Ancestry to choose a book for each of the genres. Then I narrowed it down to the five I would actually annotate for class.

      Delete
  2. Hi Sarah,
    I love your bright red blog. It fits perfectly with the thriller genre.
    Something I have struggled with in the annotations was not being able to give my opinion on the book. I always have a point of view about books, and it can often be critical.
    The plot of “These Toxic Things” is interesting, but I am just dying to ask whether you actually liked reading it. The quote you included adds a poignant layer to the narrative. I sometimes find when situations hit too close to home, like having a relative with dementia, I end up not being able to enjoy the story.
    Regarding the storyline, did you find yourself predicting the outcome early on and having your expectations confirmed as you progressed? Or did the conclusion unfold in a way that surprised you?
    Thank you for sharing such an insightful annotation and introducing us to some compelling reads.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jackie, I inadvertently injected a little bit of opinion on the appeals section. I'm honestly not sure how to avoid it on that part! I had predicted the main storyline within a couple of chapters, but there were added twists throughout due to multiple side stories.

      I somewhat enjoyed the book (if I hated it I would have stopped and picked a different one), but I don't think I would read another book by this author.

      Delete
  3. Excellent annotation! This book sounds unique and very thrilling. The way you outlined your appeals is fantastic. Great job referring to the text and overall great job on this annotation!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Erin, Did I share too much opinion on the appeals? I was not sure how to talk about whether the book fit with those appeals without sharing my reaction to the book.

      Delete
    2. Not at all! I think you did an excellent job on the appeals. It wasn't overly opinionated and you help explain how the appeals fit into the book!

      Delete
  4. Hi Sarah! Wow, the plot for this book has me intrigued. I'm adding it to my TBR for sure! I haven't heard of any other books like this. I'm curious what your thoughts are?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mallory, I liked the book enough to keep reading, but not enough to seek out other books by the same author. I think there were a few too many side plots that didn't tie together as well as I hoped at the end, but even that would have been fine if not for some unnecessary sex scenes. I don't mind them if they're integral to the plot, but if it's just randomly included I don't feel comfortable reading them.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 3 Prompt Responses

1. I am looking for a book by Laurell K. Hamilton. I just read the third book in the Anita Blake series and I can’t figure out which one comes next! Title: The Lunatic Cafe Author: Laurell K. Hamilton Published: March 1, 2005 Since the patron only needed to know the next title in the series, I searched for the author’s name, clicked on the “Series” tab, selected the Anita Blake series, and found the title of book 4.   In the real world, I use https://www.bookseriesinorder.com/ for this kind of question, because there are less steps involved in me loading that site and finding an answer.  It also is easier for me to be able to see all the author’s books on one page, as the patrons frequently ask follow-up questions about another series or the standalone books. 2. What have I read recently? Well, I just finished this great book by Barbara Kingsolver, Prodigal Summer. I really liked the way it was written, you know, the way she used language. I wouldn't mind something a bi...

Sarah: A Portrait of the Reader as a Grad Student

Greetings from Sarah!  I've lived 43 years and been a voracious reader for at least 44 of those.  I've been registering for the Goodreads Reading Challenge annually since 2011, and met my goal most years since 2013.  In 2021 and 2022, the goal kept being bumped up due to accidentally reading a marginally insane number of picture books during work, so I set it at 150 for 2023 and then...didn't read picture books.  57 out of the revised goal of 52 made 52 seem like a reasonable number for the 2024 challenge.  More challenging, however, is the goal to not purchase or check out any books in 2024, unless required for a class.  There is no shortage of books already in my house and her Kindle library - it's just hard to not grab something that's shiny and new. My favorite books that I read in 2023: If you walked into my house and looked around, your eyes would land on one of many bizarre objects, from a toy ketchup bottle in the refrigerator door to a plastic pira...