Author: Holly Rayner
I feel both reviews are reliable, in the sense that they are genuine reactions from people who read the book. I don’t believe that either was influenced by being paid for a review or by being published in a place that only accepts positive reviews. If I were in a position to select e-books for my library’s collection, I probably would not choose this one. I appreciate that one reviewer referred to it as “clean”, given the discussion we previously had on trying to find books of that nature. However, the blog reviewer seemed very conflicted about whether or not they liked the book. I’d prefer to spend the library’s budget on a book some people love and others hate, rather than one that’s mediocre.
The lack of professional reviews definitely does not help with selection for e-books. In a previous course, we addressed the library’s website as another branch of the library, in which case the digital collection needs to stand on its own as a collection, not just be random extra books for the patrons at the physical branches. My director and I have discussed in the past that this level of collection development has not been happening for our digital collection, and I don’t think it’s feasible to scour Amazon and blogs to find reviews to make those choices. It would be great if one of the existing review magazines would start a spin-off for the digital-only titles.
I’m not sure how to begin considering reviews of Angela’s Ashes under the premise of using them to make a decision about purchasing the book. If I had not already read or heard about the book, I still probably would choose it based on these overwhelmingly positive reviews, particularly the one from Kirkus (which I’m guessing also came with a Kirkus Star in the original magazine). The one hesitation I would have is that my library is overrun with memoirs, and I try to limit new selections to those by people who are well-known and will likely be popular among our patrons.
There are certain authors (ie. James Patterson) that don’t deserve any more space dedicated to reviewing their books. It doesn’t matter what the review says, because libraries are still going to buy the books and patrons are still going to check them out. Library collections are definitely impacted by bias in review magazines, both in terms of certain types of books not receiving coverage and in books potentially getting more positive reviews than the reviewers wanted to write.
As someone who selects primarily adult non-fiction (with occasional dabbles into children’s and teens’ non-fiction, multicultural picture books, graphic novels, and horror fiction), I do pull most of my selections from the review magazines. However, I also check the bestseller lists and some of the major awards to ensure that we didn’t miss a book that patrons might expect to see in our collection. Kirkus is my hands-down favorite review magazine, due to the cover photo with every book, the ease of reading first and last lines to decide whether to read the rest of a review, and the potential for finding a harsh review. I also enjoy being the last person to view a copy of Foreword Reviews, because the indie publishers are putting out different and interesting books, and by the time a magazine passes through the whole staff, the books are usually already released and the best ones have made it into Baker & Taylor’s selection.


Great prompt response!
ReplyDelete