I say “not who readers expected”, because the examples discussed in this article range from briefly mentioned pen names to detailed analysis of fake authorship that was clearly intended for malicious purposes, such as the poems attributed to Ern Malley. It seems unfair to use the word hoax in reference to writers whose purpose in using a pen name was to publish work that would not likely be published otherwise. Menand seems to agree, at least based on the very small amount of attention given to female authors who used male pen names.
Even established authors choose to use pen names - such as Stephen King writing as Richard Bachman or Nora Roberts writing as J.D. Robb - and along with that create biographies for these pen names. I do not see any criticism of this practice in Menand’s article, so it seems that the real issue here isn’t in what the authors claim to be, but in what readers have assumed that they are.
Most of the complaints described center around books where the main character has experienced a more challenging life than that of the real author or the unhappy readers. Would Oprah have felt so deceived by James Frey had his alterations to the reality of his life experience made that experience less challenging rather than more challenging? When using books as a window into other people’s experiences, do we seek a clear window, or do we secretly hope for the voyeuristic thrill that comes from watching tragedy strike?
I am not immune to that secret desire. A young coworker asked me today for help selecting books for a display, stating that I know the library’s collection better. The display was to be in our teen area, with books that would evoke the emotions represented by different emojis she had printed. I had no difficulty walking around that area and grabbing books (all of which I had personally read) off the shelf to match 😲 and 😭, but I struggled with 🤣. Even using a combination of catalog searches and articles found online, I did not feel remotely confident that the books we ended up choosing were actually humorous.
Intellectually, I don’t believe it matters who the author is. A well-written book doesn’t become less well-written if we learn new information about the author. It’s still the same book. Emotionally though, there are some situations in which I understand why it’s upsetting to learn that an author isn’t writing based on personal experiences. Some topics are so frequently treated in shallow or one-dimensional ways that it becomes clear an author has actually gone through that experience based on their treatment of the character as a multi-faceted human being with complex motivations. When the reader has had similar experiences, they feel a connection with the author. Someone else out there understands. They are not alone, not a freak, not unlovable. Discovering that the author hadn’t actually experienced the same situation would yank that connection away.
The rational response would be that if an author can describe experiences and feelings in a way that sounds authentic, the reader is still not alone. Someone understands. Someone in that author’s life has likely gone through the experience too. Emotions aren’t rational though, and in the wake of that revelation we react in ways that we wouldn't if we had more time to think.
The teen fiction book, Girl in Pieces, by Kathleen Glasgow features a main character who engages in self-harming behavior. This topic is notorious for being judged and stereotyped in fiction books, and it was apparent within the first chapter that the author understood why people would use self-harm as a coping mechanism. She understood in ways that would have sounded false if written by someone who hadn’t done that very thing.
I try to imagine discovering that I was wrong. What if that understanding was false? What if the author interviews I read discussed a life that had never happened to a person who didn’t exist? I would have been absolutely heartbroken, despite my belief that anyone can “write what they know”, but a truly talented author will make an effort to know what they write.
References
Menand, L. (2018, December 3). Literary hoaxes and the ethics of authorship. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/12/10/literary-hoaxes-and-the-ethics-of-authorship

Excellent insight! Also, I love the emoji display idea! How fun!
ReplyDelete