Over the past few months, I have been in the presence of multiple meetings of two different book clubs, ranging from partially overhearing to actively participating. All of these took place at the library where I work, so there is no avoiding the fact that participants know I work in a library.
Book Club A is led by a retired English professor and discusses literary fiction, often recent bestsellers. There are three different meeting options, and people can shift between them as needed, but most people attend the same meeting every month. The leader and most of the participants are older adults - I would estimate most are between 50 and 70 years old.
I have only listened in on their conversations, but the group seems to run smoothly. The library provides bottled water and a snack themed to the book of the month, and while none of the meeting locations are totally private, there does not tend to be much disruption from other users of the space.
The leader of Book Club A presents questions to prompt discussion, but allows those to segue into other topics. I did not notice if he eventually provides his own answers, but he definitely gives the participants a chance to answer first. The conversations seem to be well-balanced, with everyone participating, and there’s a dedicated group of members who always complete the book and participate in the discussion even if they did not like the book. On the other hand, I’ve seen new people return a book club book and say they weren’t going to finish reading “this garbage”.
I personally don’t think I would enjoy being a member of Book Club A, because the selections are often not books I would actively choose to read and I am a pro at quitting a book if I don’t like it.
Book Club B, led by a library staff member, is advertised as being “edgier”, and the book choices are much more aligned with what I would typically read. The books are aimed at readers in their 20’s, and lean toward topics of serial killers, occult horror, and other slightly unnerving stories.
As a newer club, there is not yet a large, established group of attendees. I attended two meetings of this book club. The first was for a book I intend to read eventually, but did not have time to do so before the meeting. In that case, I stated that I was there as an observer, and allowed the other three participants to mostly talk uninterrupted, aside from making a couple of contributions that were more about personal experiences than about the book.
The next month, I was excited to have made it over halfway through the book in time, but no one else showed up. The coworker who led the group discussed the first portion of it with me, and then I went home and finished reading later.
Book Club B was led with similar discussion prompts as Book Club A, but by a leader with less book club experience. The members (on the day others were present) also seem a bit nervous about talking. These facts combined meant that the discussion didn’t flow quite as smoothly. With more time to gain members and have the staff practice leading a group, I believe it could be as successful as Book Club A. The primary difference is the target audience and therefore the book selections.
Great write up! I like how the first one sounds - but like you I would be drawn to the second one!
ReplyDelete