In a hypothetical situation where we did start separating the genres, I would not separate LGBTQ fiction in our library, nor would I recommend that any other library do so, for the following reasons:
The LGBTQ aspect relates to the individual characters, and says nothing about the storyline, writing style, pacing, or other appeals we have discussed. The purpose of separating by genre is primarily to allow patrons to browse an area unassisted and be reasonably certain they will find a book they like, and an LGBTQ section would contain a wide variety of stories from romance to science fiction to westerns to horror.
Creating an LGBTQ section would interfere with patron privacy, as entering that section would imply to other patrons that the person browsing there identifies with the characters in those books. This may not even be accurate, but I’ve heard enough negative comments in my community to be concerned that it could make the readers seen browsing an LGBTQ section into a target, which would discourage those who are questioning or unable to safely come out from reading stories that validate their experience.
It would be extremely difficult to determine which books belong in an LGBTQ section - does that designation only apply to the main character? Major supporting characters? Even a passing mention that is not significant to the plot? Does the character’s sexuality need to be integral to the plot, or would we move books there even if the core of the story could be envisioned with a cisgender, heteronormative character? Circling back to point one, this separation would discourage certain readers from picking up a book they would otherwise enjoy due to their own prejudices, and those prejudices only become stronger if it’s easy to avoid exposure to stories about people with a different life experience.
I struggle more with the question of separating Urban Fiction, and this is where the difference in libraries and communities comes into play.
The settings and storylines of Urban Fiction are distinct, and a library that otherwise separates fiction by genre should consider whether Urban Fiction is a genre that gets enough requests to warrant being in its own section.
The size of the collection matters, and large metropolitan libraries are more likely to contain enough Urban Fiction titles for that section to look like an actual section and not just a display.
The community’s attitudes toward racial diversity matter, as Urban Fiction is “written mainly by, for and about African-Americans” (Munshi, 2015). Separating these books would be acceptable in a library where there are plenty of other perspectives on African-Americans represented, but in a library where patrons would see those books clustered together and assume that the themes of Urban Fiction are daily life for an entire race it would be a dangerous genre to separate.
Those aren’t exactly three reasons, but they are three factors I considered in deciding that it would be inappropriate for my current library to create an Urban Fiction section.
References
Munshi, N. (2015, November 13). Urban fiction: words on the street. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/08785ece-86ee-11e5-9f8c-a8d619fa707c
Comments
Post a Comment