Title: House of Hollow
Author: Krystal Sutherland
Genre: YA Paranormal Horror
Published: April 6, 2021
Setting: Scotland and London, England
Time Period: Present-day
“I was ten years old the first time I realized I was strange.”
- Iris Hollow (Sutherland, 2021)
Plot Summary: Ten years after the three Hollow sisters mysteriously vanished and then reappeared a month later, the youngest - 17-year-old Iris Hollow - just wants to fit in with her peers despite years of being mistreated due to the odd changes she experienced after returning from an unknown place. Her older sisters, Grey and Vivi, dropped out of school to become a fashion designer and a musician, respectively.
The three sisters are planning to reunite in London when Iris starts to notice an unsettling figure following her. The creepiness intensifies when Grey disappears again, and Iris and Vivi are left to search for her while confronting the fact that their father, who committed suicide shortly after their return ten years earlier, may have been right. They really might not be the daughters who disappeared.
Subject Headings:
Young adult fiction
Paranormal fiction
Horror fiction
Changelings
Missing persons–Fiction
Amnesia–Fiction
Horror Appeals:
Tone: The atmosphere in Horror novels must evoke an emotional response: dread and chill, a sense of menace, a feeling of terror. (Wyatt & Saricks, p. 239)
I was interested in annotating this book to do a comparison with adult horror fiction. As with the book Ghost Eaters, which I annotated for Horror week, this book was effective in evoking that sense of dread. In both cases, the authors created characters I could empathize with, and that bond seems to be the key to generating that feeling. If I did not care about the characters, I would not be on the edge of my seat stressing out about what would happen to them.
Frame/Setting: Setting is even more important than frame as it establishes tone. So critical are spaces in Horror novels that they are described more completely and vividly than the characters. (Wyatt & Saricks, p. 240)
The settings in House of Hollow were vividly described. I noted in my Ghost Eaters annotation that some settings were more vivid than others and it emphasized the importance of those settings. The vividness in House of Hollow was more consistent throughout, which created additional suspense as I never had a chance to think “oh, this is a place where bad things probably aren’t going to happen”.
Story Line: Readers do not know how the story will end, and that ending, when it comes, is often
vague, intended to sustain the menacing atmosphere rather than tie up loose ends. (Wyatt & Saricks, p. 241)
I was halfway done reading House of Hollow when I attended a book club meeting about it, and since no one else showed up the leader and I discussed only the portion I had already read. She asked me to theorize about the ending and I had literally no clue. At that point, I only had a vague notion that maybe the father, Gabe Hollow, was more deeply involved in the story than his death ten years before the book starts would imply. I was correct, although I was not correct about the nature of that involvement.
This story shifted directions frequently, leaving the reader guessing until the end. It seemed fairly well wrapped up and then…an epilogue created far more questions
Language/Style: The language in Horror novels is elaborately lush; it is full of adjectives and expletives. (Wyatt & Saricks, p. 242)
This is the appeal where I start to notice a major difference between adult horror and YA horror. The YA horror is much more subdued in regard to expletives, which also made me think about other content that might not be included in a YA book. Most adult horror that I’ve read contains at least one sex scene that may or may not be necessary for the plot, and adult horror is more likely to contain human characters doing evil things. The YA horror I’ve read in recent years tends more toward the paranormal, although older titles had quite a few stalkers and serial killers.
Characterization: The main protagonists in these books are usually haunted, shattered individuals. (Wyatt & Saricks, p. 243)
Iris, though definitely affected by her childhood disappearance, reappearance, and subsequent death of her father, seems fairly well adjusted for the circumstances. Her sisters, on the other hand, give off that shattered vibe. They’ve had career success, but don’t seem particularly happy or balanced. Placing Iris at the center of the story is contradictory to the horror appeals, but fits with marketing this as a YA book rather than an adult book.
Pacing: By creating such an erratically and unexpectedly changeable pace, authors capture the essence of living in a nightmare. Readers feel the pacing is out of control, and, by inference, so are the characters and plot. (Wyatt & Saricks, p. 244)
The pacing in House of Hollow was fairly consistent throughout. If anything, it gradually increased rather than being erratic. This made the story feel more like a thriller than horror, with the supernatural aspects being what tips it over into the horror category.
Top 3 Descriptive Terms: suspenseful, chilling, complex
YA Horror Read-Alikes:
Author: Cassandra Khaw
Published: May 2, 2023
This novella, though published for adults, could appeal to both the young adult and adult readers of House of Hollow, who were entranced with the beauty and insatiable hunger that overtook the Hollow sisters after their return to the world. Both stories are described as dark fantasies containing a theme of body horror.
Author: Alison Ames
Published: September 27, 2022
Both of these young adult horror novels contain a theme of body horror and create tension based on the idea that someone - or something - else could take on the appearance of people you know.
Author: Alexandra Sirowy
Published: August 18, 2015
Like Iris Hollow, the protagonist of this book is 17 and has no memory of what happened when she briefly disappeared as a child. Both books explore supernatural explanations for the event, but The Creeping focus more on the possibility of human evil.
Throwback YA Horror Read-Alikes:
As I couldn’t find any particularly compelling non-fiction books to recommend, let’s travel back in time and revisit some older YA titles in the horror genre.
Author: R.L. Stine
Published: August 1, 1994
The father of YA horror, R.L. Stine, cursed the poor residents of Fear Street and the worst of it happened in house number 99. This book, first in a trilogy, introduces us to the Frasier family as they move into the most terrifying home in the neighborhood.
Author: Diane Hoh
Published: July 1, 1993
The Silent Scream kicks off a series of books set at the world’s scariest college, Salem University. This is a spin-off series from Point Horror, which was written by many different authors while Diane wrote most of Nightmare Hall herself. This first book explains why the dorm Nightingale Hall is referred to as Nightmare Hall.
Title: Point Horror #50: The Yearbook
Author: Peter Lerangis
Published: April 1, 199r
As a young reader, I did not even realize the Point Horror series was a series, with the books having different authors, inconsistent cover images, and stories that could stand alone. Many popular YA horror authors from the time period contributed to Point Horror, so this selection represents a different author than the previous recommendations. The Yearbook follows high school student, David, as he works as an editor on the school yearbook and finds that someone has tampered with the layout and added disturbing drawings and poems that seem to predict who will soon die.
References
Sutherland, K. (2021). House of Hollow. Nancy Paulsen Books.
Wyatt, N. & Saricks, J. G. (2019). The readers' advisory guide to genre fiction. ALA Editions.







Comments
Post a Comment